提供免费提供频繁的服务转移
to buses Travel-cards Offering free travel Marketing and advertising Providing security
公交车travel-cards提供免费旅游市场营销和广告提供安全保障
staff Integrating buses with the new system Providing car parks
员工将公交车与新系统提供停车场
at stations Restricting car parks
在车站限制停车场
in the
在
CBD Adapting plans to
cbd调整计划
the new system TOD incentives Joint development projects Locating public development at stations Pedestrianizing streets City centre re-development projects Urban renewal projects
新系统托德激励联合开发项目定位公共开发车站pedestrianizing市中心街道发展项目城市更新项目
The CBD is
CBD是
not vital economically
不重要的经济
The system serves other sub-centres
系统提供其他分中心
The urban form is not suitable
城市形态是不适合的
Public transport
公共交通
usage is low (1)
使用较低(1)
System serves high income areas
系统服务于高收入地区
System serves low income areas
系统服务于低收入地区
(2)
(2)
(2)
(2)
The route location is not suitable
16
路线位置不合适
Buses
公共汽车
are deregulated
是不受控制的
Each tick indicates that the framework advises the corresponding policy to be implemented as a measure to enhance success.
每一秒表明框架建议相应的政策是成功实现为一个措施来提高。
(1) If local support for the project is low, these policies should be considered regardless of the outcome of the Public Transport factors.
(1)如果本地支持的项目很低,这些政策应该考虑无论公共交通因素的结果。
(2) If the transport industry does not allow the implementation of these policies, i.e. buses are deregulated, then policies recommended in the last row can help enhance the success of the system.
(2)如果交通行业不允许这些政策的实施,即公共汽车是不受控制的,然后在最后一行的政策建议可以帮助提高系统的成功。
Table 4 The degrees of success of the case study systems
表4的程度的成功案例研究系统
To have high
高
patronage To build and operate the system cost-effectively To increase public
赞助建造和运营系统低成本增加
transport usage To reduce traffic congestion and environment problems To improve the land-use and urban growth patterns Total
运输使用以减少交通拥堵和环境问题,提高土地利用和城市增长模式
Ranking
排名
Systems in: Pass.
系统:通过。
/
/
route
路线
km Vehicle
公里的车辆
load Forecast vs actual Capital cost / pass. Oper. cost /
负荷预测与实际资本成本/通过。③。成本/
17
pass. Fare-
通过。票价,
box
盒子
ratio More PT use No decline in bus use Patron. increase
比更PT使用总线使用顾客没有下降。增加
on LRT Decrease in car usage Relief in congestion Better
在轻轨交通减少汽车使用缓解拥堵更好
air quality Positive effect on city centre Positive effect on slum areas Urban growth along system
对城市空气质量的积极影响对贫民窟地区城市发展中心积极影响系统
Miami 1 8
迈阿密1 8
St Louis 8 2=
圣路易斯8 2 =
San Diego 8 2=
圣地亚哥8 2 =
Sacramento 3 6
萨克拉门托3 6
Vancouver 10 1
温哥华10 1
Tyne and Wear 6 5
泰恩-威尔郡6 5
Manchester 7 4
曼彻斯特7 4
Sheffield 2 7
谢菲尔德2 7
Nevertheless, if these design features are chosen in spite of their unsuitability, they may not necessarily hinder the success of an urban rail system. As discussed earlier, they can be addressed through policies. The first issue can be overcome by employing operating policies that can increase the attraction of the urban rail system, and help it compete with buses. The second issue can be overcome by employing additional security staff on board, at stations and in the car parks of the system.
然而,如果这些设计特点选择尽管他们不适合,他们未必阻碍城市轨道系统的成功。正如前面所讨论的,他们可以通过政策加以解决。第一个问题是可以克服的运用操作政策,可以提高城市轨道系统的吸引力,并帮助它与巴士。第二个问题可以克服采用额外的安全人员,在车站和停车场的系统。
8.Conclusion: Future Research 结论:未来的研究
18
The planning framework, the development and application of which has been described throughout this paper, has shown that it is possible to predict how successful a new urban rail system is likely to be, and that it may be possible to enhance their success. The planning framework is a tool for a comprehensive analysis of the factors that may enhance or hinder the success of urban rail systems. With the help of this framework, it will be possible to formulate policies that can enhance the success of urban rail systems, and so help to develop urban rail systems as effective alternatives to the car.
规划框架,的发展和应用已在本文描述,表明有可能预测成功的可能是一个新的城市轨道系统,而且它有可能提高他们的成功。规划框架是一个综合分析工具的因素可能促进或阻碍城市轨道系统的成功。这个框架的帮助下,可以制定政策,可以提高城市轨道系统的成功,所以帮助发展城市轨道系统有效的替代汽车。
The planning framework was developed through an in-depth analysis of case studies from the United States, Canada, and Britain. It was tested against other systems, demonstrating its validity. When applied to Turkish systems, it was also seen that the framework was capable of predicting success accurately. In addition, this exercise had implications for the further development of the framework.
规划框架是通过深入分析案例研究来自美国、加拿大和英国。它对其他系统进行了测试,证明其有效性。应用于土耳其系统时,还看到,该框架能够准确预测成功。此外,这个练习对框架的进一步发展有影响。
The application of the framework on Turkish systems revealed important results. First, some factors included in the original work may not be as important in developing countries as they are in developed countries: for example, usage and image of public transport is generally high in developing countries because a relatively higher percentage of the population are captive public transport riders. These findings may indicate that there may be factors that are very important for the success of urban rail systems in developing countries, which were not equally important for developed countries and hence not observed in the original work.
土耳其系统上的应用程序的框架显示重要成果。首先,一些因素包括在原来的工作可能不是一样重要的发展中国家在发达国家:例如,使用和公共交通的形象通常是发展中国家的高,因为相对较高的人口比例是垄断公共交通乘客。这些发现可能表明可能存在的因素是非常重要的成功的城市铁路系统在发展中国家,而不是发达国家同样重要,因此没有观察到在原始的工作。
The second finding regarding the Turkey case was the lack of supporting policies, which led to the observation that although transport and urban development plans were produced in co-ordination, there were problems in the implementation stages, which resulted in the fact that some plans were not realised. Co-ordinated planning did not have any positive impact on the rail systems because the plans were only partially realised.
第二个发现关于土耳其是缺乏配套政策,导致观察,虽然交通和城市发展计划生产的协调,实现阶段存在问题,导致一些计划并没有意识到这一事实。协同计划没有任何积极影响铁路系统,因为只有部分实现的计划。
Thirdly, there were severely contradicting policies and investments. Difficulties in implementing both transport and urban development plans, and piece-meal actions in transport investments, which are often not integrated into existing projects, seem to be among the reasons behind the conflicting policies.
第三,有严重矛盾的政策和投资。困难在实施交通和城市发展计划,和piece-meal行动在运输投资,通常没有集成到现有项目,似乎相互矛盾的政策背后的原因之一。
19
These findings show that the application of this research on urban rail systems in Third World countries may result in the production of a different planning framework. If this can be done, it would be a valuable tool which can be used throughout the urban rail planning process in Third World cities: it can help decision makers decide whether or not to build a system in a city; it can guide planners how to proceed with the investment; and it can help operators to enhance the success of their urban rail systems. In addition, because the work involves the analysis of a wide range of aspects, it can reveal both institutional and political facts, such as local governance, planning tradition, public transport operating regimes, etc., about the developing countries. Furthermore, such a research can facilitate a comprehensive comparison of urban rail planning practices in developed and developing countries.
这些发现表明这项研究的应用在第三世界国家城市轨道系统可能会导致不同的生产计划框架。如果可以,这将是一个有价值的工具,可以使用在整个城市轨道规划过程在第三世界城市:它可以帮助决策者决定是否要建立一个系统在一个城市,它可以指导规划者如何进行投资;,它可以帮助运营商提高城市轨道系统的成功。此外,由于工作涉及范围广泛的方面的分析,可以揭示制度和政治事实,如地方治理、规划的传统,公共交通运营机制,等等,对发展中国家。此外,这样的研究可以促进城市轨道规划实践的全面比较发达国家和发展中国家。
Acknowledgements
确认
The author would like to acknowledge the assistance of various experts working for the transport agencies, municipalities, and other local government organisations in Miami, St Louis, San Diego, Sacramento, Atlanta, Baltimore, Portland, San Jose, and Los Angeles in the United States; Vancouver and Calgary in Canada; Rouen in France, and Newcastle upon Tyne, Manchester, and Sheffield, in Britain. These organisations are: MetroDade Transit Agency, and Metropolitan Dade County-Planning Department in Miami; Bi-State Development Agency, East-West Gateway Co-ordinating Council, Citizens for Modern Transit, and Regional Commerce and Growth Association in St Louis; Metropolitan Transit Development Board, SANDAG (San Diego Association of Governments), and City of San Diego in San Diego; Sacramento Regional Transit District, Sacramento Area Council of Governments, City of Sacramento, and Capitol Area Development Authority in Sacramento; Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority in Atlanta; Mass Transit Administration in Baltimore; TRI-MET in Portland; Valley Transportation Authority in Santa Clara; Metropolitan Transportation Authority in Los Angeles; British Columbia Rapid Transit Company Ltd., BC Transit, Greater Vancouver Regional District, City of Vancouver, City of Burnaby, and City of Surrey in Vancouver; Calgary Transit in Calgary; Metrobus Transports en Commun de l’Agglomération Rouennaise in Rouen; Newcastle City Council and Nexus the Passenger Transport Executive in Tyne and Wear; Greater Manchester Passenger Transport Executive (GMPTE) and Manchester City Council in Manchester; South Yorkshire Passenger Transport Executive (SYPTE), Supertram Ltd., and Sheffield City Council in Sheffield. In addition, the technical assistance of Tom Parkinson, president of Transport Consulting Limited, Vancouver; Tony Young, former operational planning manager, GMPTE; John Keyworth, former Director of Planning, Sheffield Development Corporation (SDC); Patsy Healey, Simon Raybould, and John Nelson, University of Newcastle; Russ Haywood, Sheffield Hallam University; Prof. Güng?r Evren, Istanbul Technical University; and Prof. Ali Türel, Middle East Technical University are gratefully acknowledged. In addition, the author gratefully acknowledges the Middle East Technical University in Ankara, Turkey, who funded this research; University College London Centre for Transport Studies where this research was carried out; the Brian Large Trust which partially funded the study trip to North America; and the University College London
20
百度搜索“77cn”或“免费范文网”即可找到本站免费阅读全部范文。收藏本站方便下次阅读,免费范文网,提供经典小说综合文库城市轨道交通系统2(4)在线全文阅读。
相关推荐: